Click here for Home
'Lipa' by Matt Fortgang...double-click to enlarge
...aggressive roses
surround the laws with their barbed wire
in a disguise forged by troubadours
Claire Malroux, tr. by Marilyn Hacker
Home/Blog
Publications
Audio and Video
Submissions
Order
Funding
Masthead & Contact



XML FEED

Tuesday, November 01, 2005

Romance Reader (I'm not)
Word from: Jake


I have to preface this by saying that my school's library was having its annual sale, each book for $1, so I couldn't say no. I guess I'm making excuses because the title doesn't sound like anything I'd want to admit to reading.

Pearl Abraham's Romance Reader came out a decade ago. If I read it back then, I would have loved it. At this point, I've heard everything I ever wanted to hear about the "rebels" of the Chassidic community. However, the book also happens to be a coming-of-age novel, and it was specifically the combination of the two that redeemed the subject matter for me.

What I liked best, were the short deceivingly-simple punchy sentences. Up Hemingway's alley. They give the main character (rebellious Chassidish girl with a thing for romance novels) a distinct voice that I thought was very appealing. Totally realistic, heimish, prematurely mature (as the oldest sister of six), very down-to-earth. After the first thirty pages, I started yawning and massively skipping, stopping over occasionally for dialog and one or two erotic scenes. Still and all, on the whole I'm definitely happy to add it to my book collection. It was a bargain you know.

I remember hearing about The Seventh Beggar a few months ago. That's Abraham's new novel, and as far as reviews go, it sounds good. Contemporary Chassidic dilemmas in the frame-work of Rav Nachman's tale. Has anyone read it?

3 Comments:

  • At 10:28 PM, Anonymous said…

    The Seventh Beggar just came out in paperback, FYI. I couldn't get through it. Too experimental. But you may like that. The book she wrote in between was weak. The interview with her in the Times some months back was fascinating.

     
  • At 11:48 PM, Anonymous said…

    Funny to come across this. I read the book when I was 13 or 14 (I'd tuck it under my shirt and sneak it off to bed in my Chasidic home) and it had me spellbound all the way through, as I remember. . I don't think I'd like it nearly as much today, though. Haven't read Seventh Beggar though from what I've heard of it I'd ditto previous comment. . .way experimental. . The Times interview was intriguing.

     
  • At 5:04 PM, MC Aryeh said…

    "The Romance Reader" was not bad. Have heard mixed things about "The Seventh Beggar". Best Jewish fiction I've read in the past few years is definitely Joseph Skibell's "A Blessing On The Moon". Worth searching out if you have not yet read it.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home