E.L. Doctorow On Being Pigeonholed
Word from: Mordy
From the Los Angeles Times:
A novelist, he says, "partakes of many identities. People say to me, 'A lot of your novels take place in the past. Are you a historical novelist?' I don't think of myself that way, but if you want to call me that, go ahead. Then someone will say, 'There's a certain political quality to a lot of your work. Would you call yourself a political novelist?' And I'll say, 'I've never thought of myself as a political novelist, but if that suits you, why not?' And then someone will say, 'You're a Jewish novelist' — and yes, I guess that's true, too. So I accept any kind of identity. I'm willing to participate in all of them, as long as none claims to be an exhaustive interpretation."














2 Comments:
At 2:29 AM, David said…
It's interesting how the debate over who is a Jewish writer pops up again and again. I remember reading a Commentary from the late 40's with the same question-many writers didn't want to be pigeonholed as ethnic and wrote about modernity and humanism. In today's multicultural world, it's even more or less of an issue depending on whether one believe in it or not.
I suggested Elizabeth Wurtzel with same rationale as Doctorow-she could just as easily and more likely be considered many other things.
At 5:31 PM, Mordy said…
It's really weird -- when I was interviewing Ayelet Rose Gottlieb for the Forward (http://www.forward.com/articles/jazzing-up-ancient-texts/) I asked her about being a Jewish artist. Without any prodding on the pigeon-holed issue, she began speakly directly to it. The relevent paragraph in the article was:
Gottlieb, who is involved with a number of non-Jewish jazz projects, is not concerned that her latest album might pigeon-hole her. “Sometimes I consider myself a Jewish artist,” she explained. “I’m not opposed to being called that, but I don’t think I’m just that.” And, she added, “I also don’t think I’m just a jazz artist.”
I found it odd that the question of 'Are you a Jewish artist,' jumps to the pigeon-holed response.
Post a Comment
<< Home